As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Smoking a brisket can be quite challenging for beginners, and even pros. This is an interesting question that most BBQ lovers are not even bothered about sometimes. All they do is to cook the brisket without worrying whether they put the brisket fat side up or down. Brisket is a tough cut of meat. It will stress you a little as you try to tame it. Once you get it right, you will enjoy its delicious taste.
Whipping up the perfect brisket
If you are a meat or BBQ pro, you must have gone to the butcher to get your different meat cuts. Each cut can be cooked differently. The key to a great smoked brisket is combining the rub recipe with the perfect smoking technique. This guide features the rub recipe and smoking technique whether you put the brisket fat side up or down. Keep reading to learn more!
Master the ingredients
Before deciding to cook the brisket fat side up or down, you need to master some elements that will give you the desired flavor. Choose the quantity according to how large or small your brisket is.
- Chili pepper
- Dried mustard
- Brown sugar
- Granulated garlic
- Onion powder
- Dried oregano
- Dried thyme
- Smoked salt or ordinary regular salt
- Cayenne pepper
- Black and white pepper
The dry mop ingredients are as follows:
- Brown sugar
- Dried mustard
- Red pepper flakes
- Smoked salt (you can use whatsoever you have)
- White and black pepper
Before smoking a brisket fat side up or down, you need to understand some basic things involved.
What is it about brisket?
If you have not smoked before but plan to do so, you should know that the brisket has two sides.
- One side is covered with fat, while the other is relatively free of fat.
- Whenever you look at the brisket from one side to the other, you will be able to differentiate between the area that has more fat and the flat side with less fat.
The issue is about which side should be touching the grill when barbequing, the fat side or the lean side. That is, should the fat area touch the rack or the lean side?
Assumptions and the facts
Some BBQ pros say cooking the fat side up is the best choice. They believe that the melting fat bastes the meat by keeping the meat moist. Others say that the fat side will braise the chicken and mix it inside the meat.
Anyway, let’s find out!
Fat doesn’t penetrate the meat:
When the fat side melts and turns into a liquid, it drips into the pan or smoker, taking away with it any spices you added earlier. It will prevent the meat from drying the side it’s on whether up or down, but not the entire brisket.
If you want to know whether this is true or not, grill a steak to your taste. Then, slap on a slab of butter, and see how much is absorbed. You will notice that it just melts and runs off the side.
The fat side breaks down the meat as it cooks, making it tender and juicy:
This is just an assumption as it’s the collagen that breaks down tenderizing the brisket. Collagen is the connective tissue that holds the muscle fibers together. It takes long slow cooking to break down the collagen.
That’s why BBQ pros cook brisket at a relatively low-temperature heat source of 225 degrees Fahrenheit for some hours instead of cooking at higher temperatures for less time. The long slow cooking gives the collagen plenty of time to break down and tenderize the brisket.
A little about braising
Braising is a cooking technique where the meat is first seared then slowly simmered in a flavored liquid in a covered pot. While you smoke the brisket, it rests on a grill grate without a pan, nor braising at this point. You don’t braise with fat; you fry with fat. People that say the fat braises the brisket are wrong.
Techniques/tips to improve
Since this debate of whether to cook brisket fat side up or down has been going on for long. We’ve decided to take a look at that. You can probably decide on which technique to use.
Should you cook the brisket fat side up?
Most people prefer to cook brisket fat side up since they think that the fat acts as a shield by protecting the meat. Fat side up is preferable, especially if you are using a horizontal offset smoker as the heat source is mostly from the top.
Check your brisket periodically to prevent the unprotected bottom from drying out. However, if your brisket starts to get dry, just wrap it with paper or foil so you can finish your cooking.
Malcolm Reed has an easy smoked brisket recipe. This professional pitmaster prefers to cook brisket fat side up. He wraps his brisket in foil about four hours into cooking, thereby preventing drying as the heat comes from the smoker. He uses a horizontal offset smoker for his recipe.
Aaron Franklin also uses the fat side up with an offset smoker. The fat layer still faces the heat.
- Protects the meat from heat from the top
- Forms a thick bark on the unprotected bottom
- Delivers more fat
- Washes off rub as cooking fat melts it
What about cooking it fat side down
Most people also prefer cooking their brisket fat side down, maybe to protect the meat from burning when the heat source is high.
Another reason for preferring fat side down is that the fat side doesn’t absorb smoke as well as lean meat. Some BBQ pros use a spray bottle of water or juice to sprinkle over the meat. They think that it helps retain moisture for a longer time, but most importantly, to let the moisture mix and create a better bark.
The fat cap should be placed down to allow easy spritzing of the meat side on top. Others feel that whether they spritz the meat or not, they will still get a better back formation with the meat side down.
Another reason to cook fat side down is that the fat does not stick to the grate as the meat sometimes does. It is not suitable for the meat to stick, as it can ruin your presentation at serving time.
Malcolm Reed said he likes cooking his brisket fat side down. He then trims off all the fat and injects the brisket with liquid to get it moist.
Meathead Goldwyn cooks his brisket fat side down. His reason is that the fat drips down into the fire, and the resulting smoke flavors the meat. The cooking fat cap is saved and put on the grate over the fire and let it drip away.
- Shields the meat from bottom heat
- Gives a better bark formation
- Your meat side won’t get stuck to the grill grates
- The meat might get dried by the top heat
Most cooks prefer to start smoking with the fat side down for some time before flipping it during the last part of the cooking. They feel it allows spices to get into the meat and also creates a smooth bark.
Flipping and rotating the brisket is a good thing, especially if your smoker has hot spots or a non-uniform temperature gradient either from side to side or top to bottom. If one part of your smoker is more heated than another, the meat cooks fast and also dries out faster. The meat can be overcooked before the chicken in the cooler zone is done. This could happen with some offset smokers where the side facing the firebox is often hotter.
You should know why flipping over the meat while cooking is a good idea. This is because it will even out the exposure to the higher heat, and promote a more even cook. It also allows one side of the meat to rest and reabsorb the moisture while it is not close to the heat, especially when using a horizontal smoker.
- Offers a more uniform bark
- Reduces any chance of the meat side drying out
- Helps in creating even cooking in an uneven temperature gradient cooker
- The meat could stick to the grill grate if you first cook with fat side up
- The fat could tear during flipping and release excess moisture from the meat
Correcting common problems
Some problems usually occur when cooking briskets. It could result from the type of smoker you’re using.
Does it matter where the heat comes from?
- Most traditional BBQ grills and smokers produce heat from below though some offset smokers generate heat from the top.
- Always know that the fat side of the brisket is supposed to be in direct contact with the heat. The brisket should be cooked fat-side down if the heat comes from below.
- For a horizontal offset smoker or another similar BBQ that delivers heat from above, the brisket should be cooked fat side up.
Understand your smoker
It is the cooker’s design and functioning that determines whether the brisket should be cooked fat side up or down. You need to understand your cooker’s operation before you start smoking.
The insulation provided by the fat against direct heat helps the brisket not to dry out. The lean side of the brisket can still become dry even if it is away from the heat source. To prevent that from happening, wrap it with aluminum foil to maintain its moisture. Avoid the mistake of allowing the lean side to face the direct heat because it will become scorched.
Analysis of best practices in the industry
- Ensuring the animals will be protected by the farmers and cattle rearers
- The best practices program for calf rearing is the survival of the fittest
- There have to be colostrums feeding in the first 15-30 minutes
- Weaning is very crucial in calf rearing
- There are ones that raise a right calf every year, and the ones that breed back the cattle
- The cattle are managed in such a way that they adapt to the natural environment
- Calves are castrated at an early age within 2-3 months
- There should be a vaccination schedule for the animals
- Sick animals are always isolated
- Disbudding is done at old age. The horns are later left for them to use for protection
- Having a cow that lives and reproduces and raises a calf every year is what is being done since they’re in the business of producing beef
- Tag the ears for proper identification
Tools you can use
Having the right tool for the job is very important. Investing in the right tools for your grill or smoker makes your life easier and also improves the quality of your BBQ. Below are the valuable tools for your smoking.
- Meat thermometer
- Cooking gloves (heat resistant)
- Wireless thermometer single & dual
- Heavy-duty spatula and tongs
- Silicone basting brush
- Grill basket
- Cast iron griddle pan
- BBQ cleaning tool
- A sharp boning knife for trimming
- Rib racks
- A stainless steel grill basket
- Black disposable gloves
What side of the brisket goes up?
Flip and rotate your brisket at any time. If you want the fat to shield the meat from the fire, it is better to leave it fat side down for some time. The side of the brisket that goes up depends on your choice.
How do you cook a brisket fat side up?
The first thing is for you to get your meat. You can decide whether to smoke a whole brisket or not. Start by preparing your brisket by trimming the fat cap to ¼ inch or less. Rub it with your favorite seasoning paste or dry spice rub. You can also decide to use only salt and pepper. After doing all these, rest the meat overnight in your refrigerator to helps the flavors penetrate, or you can season it and cook right away.
Set your smoker for gentle, indirect heat. On a gas grill, light only one of the burners. Add a few pieces of your desired wood for smoke, and place your brisket away from the heat. Set your temperature to 225 degrees Fahrenheit or less. Smoke the brisket for up to 14 hours, depending on the size until it is moist and tender when using a fork.
Do you cook a tri-tip fat side up?
You can start with the fat side up if you want. If you put the thick area of the tri-tip on the fire first, the moisture will come up through the meat and make it tender.
Should you flip a brisket?
Flipping a brisket helps even out the exposure of the meat to heat. Airflow inside any smoker is uneven, and allowing the brisket to sit in one place for long can cause part of it to dry out. It is good to flip and rotate your brisket at least once while cooking.
When should I wrap my brisket in foil?
It is recommended that you wrap your brisket when your meat hits 150 degrees Fahrenheit internally. This will make it build a beautiful bark on the outside of the flesh and also offer a beautiful red smoke ring.
If you have cooked briskets before, you will know that the part that is closer to the heat gets dryer. Everyone cooks their briskets according to how it suits them.
It is good to know your smoker, identify where the heat is coming from, and place the fat cap between the heat and meat. It is better to flip your briskets once in a while when cooking.
We hope you’ve found this review useful. If you enjoyed it, then you can also share it and clear up some doubts.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.